Why Etsy Shouldn’t Be Your Only Solution as a Creative Business Owner

Etsy Is a Tool—Not a Business Plan

Etsy used to be the go-to marketplace for handmade, artisan-made, and creative businesses. A place where people came to find unique, high-quality goods crafted by real artists, makers, and small business owners.

But let’s be real—Etsy isn’t what it used to be.

It’s turned into a mass-produced crap storm flooded with cheap junk from China, dropshipped products, and even Temu resellers trying to pass off factory-made goods as "handmade."

Consumers are noticing. It’s harder than ever to stand out, and if you’re a real maker trying to sell authentic handmade goods, you’re getting buried under a pile of knockoffs and mass-produced garbage.

That’s why Etsy cannot be your only strategy. If you’re building your creative business on Etsy alone, you’re setting yourself up for frustration, shrinking profits, and a whole lot of wasted energy.

Here’s why you need to diversify and take control of your business.

1. Etsy Controls Everything—And They Can Shut You Down Anytime

At the end of the day, Etsy owns your shop. They decide:

• What products are allowed (while somehow letting mass-produced junk slide)
• How much you pay in fees (which keep increasing)
• Whether your shop stays open or gets shut down—sometimes without warning

If you wake up one day to find your shop suspended, shadowbanned, or suddenly invisible in search results, there’s nothing you can do about it.

That’s why it’s critical to have your own website and independent marketing strategy—so that Etsy isn’t your only source of income.

2. You’re Competing With Mass-Produced Junk (And It’s Getting Worse)

Etsy’s original promise was to be a marketplace for handmade, vintage, and unique goods. But now?

• Temu sellers and dropshippers are flooding the platform
• Mass-produced factory items are outselling real handmade goods
• The search algorithm prioritizes high-sales, low-quality listings

This means you, the real artisan, are constantly being undercut by cheaper, factory-made products that shouldn’t even be on Etsy in the first place.

And it’s not just frustrating for sellers—buyers are noticing the decline in quality too. More and more customers are realizing that Etsy isn’t the handmade haven it once was, and they’re starting to look elsewhere for authentic, well-made goods.

That’s why having your own brand presence off Etsy is essential.

3. Etsy Fees Keep Rising—And They’re Taking Your Profits

Selling on Etsy isn’t cheap.

• 6.5% transaction fee per sale
• 3-4% payment processing fee
• $0.20 per listing (even if the item doesn’t sell)
• 15% mandatory offsite ad fee (if Etsy advertises your product and someone buys within 30 days)

All of this eats into your profit—especially when Etsy’s algorithm decides to show mass-produced junk over your work.

When you have your own website, you keep more of your earnings and don’t have to worry about Etsy taking a bigger and bigger cut every year.

So, What Should You Do Instead?

If you’re still using Etsy, that’s fine—it can be a tool in your business, but it shouldn’t be your entire business. Here’s how to start taking back control:

1. Build Your Own Website

Having your own store on Shopify, WooCommerce, or Wix gives you full control over your business—no algorithm changes, no random suspensions, no fighting against Temu junk.

2. Start an Email List

Social media platforms and Etsy traffic can disappear overnight, but your email list is yours forever. Build a direct relationship with your customers so you’re not relying on Etsy to bring in sales.

3. Sell on Multiple Platforms

Consider selling at:

• Local markets & craft fairs (customers love meeting the maker!)
• Your own website (where you don’t compete with mass-produced junk)
• Social media (Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, Pinterest)
• Wholesale to local boutiques

It’s Time to Take Back Your Creative Business

Etsy might be a starting point, but it’s not a sustainable strategy for a real, long-term creative business. If you’re serious about growing your art business, craft business, or handmade brand, it’s time to stop relying on Etsy and start building something you actually own.

What’s your experience with Etsy lately? Have you noticed the flood of mass-produced junk? Drop a comment—I’d love to hear your thoughts!

‍